Skip to main content

Canadian Critique: A Response

One hardly knows where to begin. Although he claims to be Canadian, Mr Bugos apparently remains ignorant of the fact that Canadian health care is not socialized. Of course, he also believes that anyone disagreeing with him is either a socialist or -- worse -- a Soviet. 


I appreciate that Mr Bugos is Canadian and that I am not; however, this renders his at times factual mischaracterization of Canadian health care all the more baffling. Essentially, his argument is one long assertion without supporting data; also, he states things like “economics teaches us” as if he were advancing a truism rather than a debatable point. A couple of observations:
  • Unlike the Veteran's Administration in the United States, Canadian health care is not socialized: The government does not own and operate the means of production or service. Instead, the thirteen provincial and territorial governments administer tax-financed insurance a la Medicare (the name of the Canada’s health care system) to reimburse private providers. Thus, there is no "state monopoly in the provision of Medicare." The national government serves to set standards and to negotiate on behalf of the Canadian people. That's a good thing;
  • The genesis of the Canadian health care system goes back to the mid 40s. It arose as a result of need, not a left-wing scheme to undermine the free market. Canadians believed that the free market had failed to provide equal access to quality care. The system that emerged is a statement of pragmatism, not ideology;
  • Government regulation of health care is the common denominator of the health care systems of every developed nation. All -- even the United States -- have concluded to varying degrees that the health of their country and the people who reside there cannot hope to succeed based on rates of return;
  • Canadians like their health care system. In 2003, 57% of Canadians reported satisfaction with their health care, compared with 25% of Americans. (Danes, who have a true socialized system, register the highest degree of satisfaction at over 90%);
  • The World Health Organization does not share Mr Bugos' assessment of the poor quality of Canadian health care: It ranks their system ahead of ours (30th to 37th). Canadians live longer than Americans and have a healthier life expectancy. Their maternal mortality rate is lower than ours, and they even smoke less. And, of course, Canada accomplishes this while spending less than we do. Mr Bugos' understanding of quality seems to have the same relationship to reality as the Land of Oz;
  • Canada’s health care system reflects a national egalitarian ethos that exceeds that of the United States or even France;
  • The argument that American health care somehow serves as a safety valve to relieve pressure on other systems is a canard never accompanied even by anecdotes, much less actual evidence. I am immersed in this stuff, and have yet to see this particular claim seriously advanced. Here is an anecdote: One of my MHA colleagues is an interventional cardiologist, i.e., a heart surgeon. By no means is he the class liberal. Someone asked him if he had many Canadian patients fleeing the supposed inadequacies of Canada’s secondary care. He was genuinely puzzled by the question. Even someone extremely wealthy, he explained, would think twice about paying 100K for a procedure that would be performed in Canada both free and perfectly well;
  • Why does Mr Bugos cite 1904 AMA restrictions as an example of unwarranted state intervention? The AMA is a private organization. This is a case of the market imposing artificial controls, not the state;
  • American history suggests that when the money gets big enough (i.e., railroads, oil, telecommunications), unregulated markets will consolidate until a few major competitors emerge as price setters, a development in health care that most Americans would find unacceptable. Mr Bugos does not address this as even a possibility even though history suggests that it is a likelihood;
  • Mr Bugos writes that the United States government "forced" employers to contribute to health care, the presumes to lecture about what "economics teaches us." Had Mr Bugos passed his freshman Econ class, he would know that payroll taxes are inevitably passed on to consumers. Moreover, Mr Bugos ignores altogether the impact of the Revenue Act of 1954, which established a tax exemption for employer-provided health care benefits. In what way is that government coercion?
  • In the same paragraph. Mr Bugos accuses the United States government of sabotaging the free market, then touts its relative freedom. Admittedly, by then I didn't know whether he was coming or going either.
Overall, Mr Bugos makes an argument typical of the ones advanced by privatizers: It assumes a debatable premise and proceeds from there, rather than constructing a theory supported by underlying data. The result consists of cherry-picking, ad hominem attacks, and straw men. 

Popular posts from this blog

Best Food Allergy Tweets/Posts From 2013 ACAAI Meeting

Sorry, guys...I've been very busy the last couple of weeks, but just over a week ago one of the largest allergy and asthma conferences, the annual American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, was tweeting its brains out.

Here were the tweets and (virtual) presentations I thought were most interesting:

ACE inhibitors are often used to treat high blood pressure. I believe Lisinopril was the one specifically mentioned. This goes hand in hand with the idea that older patients, especially men, can see changes in the severity of their allergic reactions as they age.

Here's an answer on the question many of us asked about component testing. Just as with RAST, the number itself doesn't matter; just the positive result.

Gross! But yes, give your kids the bobber after the dog/ brother/ mailman licked it.

Conversely, tree-nut-allergic individuals have a 30% incidence of concurrent peanut allergy. 
So stop blaming yourselves, FA mommies! I've said this consistently - Mother Natur…

Taking The High Road With Food Allergies (Sometimes)

I was getting all ready to write a post about how grateful I am. You know...one of those count-down-to-Thanksgiving posts where I list all the people or things that have helped me along the way.

And I am grateful. Really. Having virtual friends who have traveled this same food-allergy road is a wonderful gift. I can name so many times when my panic and frustration were alleviated by someone I've never even met in real life, but who took the time to give me a tip, or to console me.

But frankly, my lovely gratitude post went out the window when I received this email from a relative:

What can we bring to share? I have some ideas: Sweet Potatoes glazed with Chutney and Ginger, Green beans with Dijon and Caper sauce, Creamed Green beans with Dill sauce, or whatever you request.   I am aware of [FAB's son] dietary restriction.

My son is allergic to beans. We avoid all beans. Even green beans. The doctor was surprised by this, as green beans are the least allergenic of the bean family, b…

Beans, Beans and More (or Less) Allergenic Beans!

We have a little good news this week: my son passed a home bean challenge for both pinto and cannellini (white) beans last night. Hooray!

At our last allergist visit, they ran the numbers on a number of varieties of beans and many were Class 0, with values like 0.68. My son's doctor thought it was reasonable to try these at home.

Going to stop for a moment and interject: DON'T DO THIS WITHOUT YOUR DOCTOR'S DIRECTION. A lot of things go into whether home challenges are a good idea for your child: how serious the allergen typically is, how far the hospital, how experienced the parents are with recognizing reactions. Many doctors are not comfortable with this at all. But, in our case, it makes sense to do some challenges at home because my son tests slightly allergic to dozens of foods.

He has avoided all beans since around age five, when he started developing new allergies. First it was tuna. Then cashews. Then (to our great surprise), he suddenly became allergic to garbonzo be…