Skip to main content

Show Me Your Allergy Papers!!

I listened in to the UKnow peanut test webinar at lunch today. (They have promised to post the presentation on their site later in the week.)

The information was mostly expected, but still very good. They had the research head of Thermo Fisher (the parent company) as well as a clinician who had implemented the testing in her practice with a great deal of success.

However, what struck me most were the questions once the initial presentation was over. The very first question asked was regarding Ara h 6. The inquirer didn't come right out and say he had heard the test wasn't reliable...but the question was clearly underneath. A couple questions later, we heard:
If my child is negative to Ara h 2 today, that doesn't mean he won't become allergic down the road, right? There's no guarantee?
The doctor with the clinical practice laughed a little when she heard the question. And then, she went through the reassurance tap dance that I'm sure she's done hundreds of times in her practice: yes, allergies can develop at any time but a passed peanut challenge generally means the child can eat peanuts. The test indicates the challenge will be low-risk. They'll take every precaution. They've never had a serious problem.

I was struck by the wide gulf between what the doctors and scientists were trying to communicate, and what the parents on the other end were willing and able to hear. As I've talked about in other blog posts, some parents do not really want to know if their child is allergic. Perhaps precautions are too ingrained. Perhaps "food allergies" have become a convenient repository for other anxieties. Perhaps no guarantee will ever be enough of a guarantee.

While I listened to rest of the presentation, I thought about this gulf between science and emotion. It also led to thoughts of the gulf between a provable allergy (science) and what we ask from society (emotion) as a result of an allergy. I thought about the social ramifications of this test. 

Right now, the test is being marketed to parents who presumably want it. But if they really don't want to know...but still want that 504 with all its jump-through hoops...who else might have an investment in the outcome of this test?

Schools. Lawyers. Even other parents who are angry about peanut-free-only treats.

Think about it. A couple of years from now, the "my child needs a 504" conversation may be countered with "have you pursued component testing?"

I have mixed feelings about all of this. There are some allergic reactions that will probably happen as a result of atypical molecular allergy patterns. That's unfortunate. On the other hand, those children will firmly know they have an allergy.

There's a whole other side of me that says "YES! Test EVERYBODY!" For too long, advocacy and safety efforts for food allergies have languished because so many people believe they have a food allergy when they don't. If there really is a way to become a card-carrying IgE-mediated, truly-at-risk allergic citizen, shouldn't those of us with allergic children support the effort?

No offense, but I would like nothing better than to say good-bye to this blog and all of you as the result of my child passing a test like this. Unfortunately, one of the first questions I asked was "if a child has had an in-office challenge and failed, is there any point to the test?" The answer was "no, no clinical reason." However, if proving his allergy and thereby having people take it more seriously was a social outcome, I would spend the money in a heartbeat. 

I don't know how this will all play out. I don't know much about 504 law and whether schools can require medical test results in exchange for accommodations. But my guess is, even if they cannot legally do so, there will be social pressures to pony up results before other parents are willing to place restriction on their own children. 

I am uncomfortably aware that the "show me your papers" portion of the Arizona immigration law was deemed constitutional by the Supreme Court this week. Can "show me your allergy papers" really be that far behind? 


Follow me on Facebook or Twitter  

Popular posts from this blog

Turn Trash to Treasure: An Easy Way to Help SAGE and the Corvallis Environmental Center!

Clear clutter and unwanted items from your home and you can help raise funds for the Corvallis Environmental Center--all year long!  Just take your unwanted items to an ARC Thrift Store where they sell them and donate the proceeds to the CEC.  It easy!  Here's how:

1. Collect Items in Good Condition

Not all donate-able items are eligible, so check out the list of items that will raise money for the CEC:
www.corvallisenvironmentalcenter.org/turn-trash-to-treasure
2. Put a sticker on each eligible item Stickers are located in a big envelope on the window outside of the CEC office at 214 SW Monroe Ave., Corvallis

3. Drop-off Items at The ARC! Items can be dropped off anytime during store hours at either location.

The ARC Thrift Stores:
928 NW Beca Street, Corvallis (541) 754-9011
936 Main Street, Philomath (541) 929-3946

Hours:
Monday-Saturday: 10am-5:30pm
Sunday: 12pm-5:30pm
Thanks so much for helping support SAGE and the other programs of the Corvallis Environmental Center!!!

Beans, Beans and More (or Less) Allergenic Beans!

We have a little good news this week: my son passed a home bean challenge for both pinto and cannellini (white) beans last night. Hooray!

At our last allergist visit, they ran the numbers on a number of varieties of beans and many were Class 0, with values like 0.68. My son's doctor thought it was reasonable to try these at home.

Going to stop for a moment and interject: DON'T DO THIS WITHOUT YOUR DOCTOR'S DIRECTION. A lot of things go into whether home challenges are a good idea for your child: how serious the allergen typically is, how far the hospital, how experienced the parents are with recognizing reactions. Many doctors are not comfortable with this at all. But, in our case, it makes sense to do some challenges at home because my son tests slightly allergic to dozens of foods.

He has avoided all beans since around age five, when he started developing new allergies. First it was tuna. Then cashews. Then (to our great surprise), he suddenly became allergic to garbonzo be…

Best Food Allergy Tweets/Posts From 2013 ACAAI Meeting

Sorry, guys...I've been very busy the last couple of weeks, but just over a week ago one of the largest allergy and asthma conferences, the annual American College of Allergy, Asthma and Immunology, was tweeting its brains out.

Here were the tweets and (virtual) presentations I thought were most interesting:

ACE inhibitors are often used to treat high blood pressure. I believe Lisinopril was the one specifically mentioned. This goes hand in hand with the idea that older patients, especially men, can see changes in the severity of their allergic reactions as they age.

Here's an answer on the question many of us asked about component testing. Just as with RAST, the number itself doesn't matter; just the positive result.

Gross! But yes, give your kids the bobber after the dog/ brother/ mailman licked it.

Conversely, tree-nut-allergic individuals have a 30% incidence of concurrent peanut allergy. 
So stop blaming yourselves, FA mommies! I've said this consistently - Mother Natur…